Semtrio
ACADEMY
Partner Login
Contact

By subscribing you agree to receive marketing communications from Semtrio. You can unsubscribe at any time.

Be the first to know what’s changing.

Semtrio
Follow us on

Services

Compliance and RegulatoryClimate AccountingSustainability ReportingClimate and Sustainability StrategySupply Chain Sustainability
ESG RatingsSustainable FinanceCapacity Building and TrainingCarbon Markets and Climate Projects

Industries

ManufacturingEnergyAviationFinance and Banking
TelecomsRetail and ConsumerConstruction MaterialsGroup Companies and Holdings

Works

All Clients & ProjectsKey ProjectsAccreditations

Insights

Case StudiesBlogsGlossaryResources

About

Who We AreWhy SemtrioWork With Us

Contact

Contact Us

Our Partners

B Corp Certified
CDP
UN Global Compact
Ecovadis CoreEcovadis Platinum
GRI Community Member

Copyright © 2026 All Rights Reserved.

Legal
Policies
Peerless Ventures

Designed by

Fameus
Home
Insights
Blog
Choosing a CBAM consultant: 6 questions to ask before you sign

Blog

Choosing a CBAM consultant: 6 questions to ask before you sign

CBAMCBAM consultantCBAM reporting serviceCBAM declarantembedded emissionsdefault valuesCBAM verificationCBAM 2027

Publish: 18 Nov 26Reading Time: 7 Min

To choose a CBAM consultant, ask six questions: which side of CBAM the firm works on, whether it calculates embedded emissions per installation and CN code, how it replaces default values with actual data, what it hands over, whether it is independent of your verifier, and how it proves its results. The answers show whether you are buying a declaration-ready dataset or a report. The timing matters: the first annual CBAM declaration, for goods imported in 2026, is due by 30 September 2027.

Last checked: 18 November 2026.

Why does the choice of CBAM consultant matter now?

Since 1 January 2026 CBAM is in its definitive regime, and it now has a price. An authorised CBAM declarant declares the embedded emissions in the previous year's imports and surrenders the matching number of CBAM certificates, after the deduction for a carbon price paid abroad and the free allocation adjustment. Certificates go on sale from 1 February 2027, and from 2027 declarants must hold at least 50% of the year-to-date requirement at the end of each quarter.

That changes what a consultant is for. In the transitional period, the job was a complete quarterly report. Now every tonne declared on a default value, or a figure that cannot be defended in a review, costs money. The consultant you want works on the data that sets that cost, not only on the form that reports it.

Which six questions should you ask?

Comparison of a CBAM report and a declaration-ready dataset: figures per installation, default-value lines ranked by cost and the correct certificate price basis

1. Which side of CBAM do you work on: the declarant, the installation, or both?

CBAM has two sides. The declarant is the EU importer, or an indirect customs representative acting as authorised CBAM declarant, and it files the declaration. The installation operator outside the EU produces the goods and holds the data. A consultant who only knows the declarant side will chase suppliers for numbers; one who only knows the installation side will produce numbers your declaration process cannot use.

If you import from several suppliers, ask how the firm handles a supplier who sends nothing usable. Our guide to requesting CBAM data from suppliers shows what that request should contain.

A consultant cannot file for you unless it is your indirect customs representative with authorised declarant status. Under the CBAM Regulation, only the authorised declarant submits the declaration in the CBAM Registry.

2. Do you calculate per installation and per CN code, with precursors?

Embedded emissions are calculated per type of goods, with system boundaries aligned with the EU ETS and relevant precursors included (Article 7 and Implementing Regulation (EU) 2025/2547). For most iron and steel goods and for aluminium only direct emissions count; for cement and fertilisers, indirect emissions count too. Ask to see one worked calculation for a good like yours, with the precursor chain visible.

3. Where will you replace default values, and what is that worth?

Default values set by the Commission are the fallback when actual data is missing, and they include a mark-up; our post on CBAM cost modelling for 2026 to 2034 shows how the gap grows. A useful first deliverable is a list of every import line on default values, ranked by the certificates it would add. Ask whether the cost model uses the right price basis: the quarterly average of EU ETS auction prices for 2026 imports, and a weekly average from 2027.

4. What exactly will you hand over?

"A CBAM report" is not a deliverable. Ask for a list that matches what the declaration needs under Article 6(2): quantities per type of goods, embedded emissions per tonne, the certificate number after both adjustments, and the evidence behind each figure. Ask how the evidence file is organised: the declarant must keep these records until the end of the fourth year after the year the declaration was due, and the Commission can review declarations within that period.

For installation operators, the handover should also include the monitoring record behind the calculation and, where you choose it, registration in the Registry's O3CI portal so that buyers can access your data there.

5. Are you independent of your verifier?

Where embedded emissions are based on actual emissions, they must be verified by an accredited verifier. Verification is one step in the cycle, and the CBAM rules keep it separate from advice. Under Delegated Regulation (EU) 2025/2551, a verifier that develops part of an operator's monitoring and reporting process, such as the monitoring methodology, the monitoring plan or the emissions report, faces an unacceptable risk to its impartiality. Impartiality is also compromised where the consultant and the verifier share ownership, management or finances. Ask both firms to confirm they have no such link.

6. How do you prove your results, and what does your team keep?

Look for CBAM results you can check: which sectors, which period, which reporting cycles, and a case you can read. Then ask what your team holds when the engagement ends: the calculation files, the evidence file, and someone in-house who can explain each figure. If only the consultant can explain your numbers, next year starts from zero.

Which red flags should end the conversation?

Red flag Why it matters
"We will submit your declaration" from a firm that is not your representative Only the authorised CBAM declarant submits in the CBAM Registry
One emissions figure per supplier Declarations work per type of goods and installation, not per supplier
No view of which lines sit on default values That list is where most of the avoidable cost is
Cost estimates with one price for every year 2026 imports use quarterly averages, 2027 imports onwards weekly averages
The same group offers to prepare and verify your data Verifier impartiality is compromised by such a link
Results with no sector, period or way to check them You cannot compare a claim with nothing behind it

What questions should you ask in the first meeting?

  1. Do you work with declarants, installations or both, and on which goods?
  2. Can we see an anonymised calculation for a good like ours, with precursors?
  3. Which of our import lines would you move off default values first, and why?
  4. What will we hold at the end: files, evidence and a named owner per figure?
  5. Can you confirm in writing that you have no link with our verifier?
  6. What are your CBAM results, with numbers and sectors?

The same logic applies to other frameworks; compare it with our checklist for choosing an IFRS S1 and S2 reporting advisor.

What we see in practice

The cost of CBAM is decided in the installation data, long before the declaration. At Tosyalı Holding, scope was set for each production entity first: export volumes and processes needing calculation. Embedded emissions were then quantified from production-level data and sector-specific emission factors, every calculation and cost estimate went through an internal technical review, and quarterly submission packages were prepared for each site across nearly twenty production entities. The same cycle was extended to wire rod, rolling mill, structural steel and spiral pipe operations, including sites in Algeria.

Our CBAM work so far: every quarterly submission deadline met in the transitional period. Past results, not a guarantee of future outcomes.

Frequently asked questions

Can a CBAM consultant act as our authorised declarant?

Only if it is your indirect customs representative and holds the status of authorised CBAM declarant. Otherwise the consultant prepares the figures and evidence, and the declarant submits the declaration in the CBAM Registry.

Can the same firm prepare our CBAM data and verify it?

No. Under the CBAM accreditation and verification rules, a verifier that has developed part of an operator's monitoring and reporting process faces an unacceptable risk to its impartiality, and a verifier linked to the consultancy that did has a conflict of interest. Keep the two roles with separate firms.

Do non-EU exporters need a CBAM consultant?

The legal obligation to declare sits with the EU declarant. Exporters are asked for installation data, and without it their buyers fall back on default values. Whether you need outside help depends on how many installations and goods you supply; our post on CBAM supplier readiness in Türkiye covers the exporter's side.

When should we hire a CBAM consultant for the 2026 declaration?

Early enough to have 2026 actual data calculated and verified before the declaration is due on 30 September 2027. Importers also need a certificate plan for the 50% quarterly holding requirement that applies from 2027.

What should a CBAM consultant's proposal include?

A scope by installation and CN code, a list of the deliverables matched to the declaration's content, a cost view based on default versus actual values, a timeline to 30 September 2027 and a statement of independence from your verifier.

Related reading: Requesting CBAM data from suppliers · CBAM cost modelling 2026–2034 · Authorised CBAM declarant and the 50-tonne threshold

Before you sign, ask for the list of your import lines on default values with the certificates each one adds; CBAM accounting and reporting starts there, line by line, with the installation data needed to replace them.

Sources

  • Regulation (EU) 2023/956, consolidated text after Regulation (EU) 2025/2083 (Arts 5, 6, 7, 8, 19, 20, 21, 22; Annex II) – https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:02023R0956-20251020 (checked 2026-11-18)
  • Regulation (EU) 2025/2083 amending Regulation (EU) 2023/956 (recitals on the annual deadline and the 50% rule; Art. 5(1a), 5(2), 5(2a); Art. 36 application dates) – https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32025R2083 (checked 2026-11-18)
  • Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2025/2551 on accreditation and verification, Annex II, Sections 1.7.2 and 1.7.3 – https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32025R2551 (checked 2026-11-18)
  • European Commission – CBAM definitive regime – https://taxation-customs.ec.europa.eu/carbon-border-adjustment-mechanism/cbam-definitive-regime_en (checked 2026-11-18)
  • European Commission – CBAM legislation and guidance (Implementing Regulation 2025/2547) – https://taxation-customs.ec.europa.eu/carbon-border-adjustment-mechanism/cbam-legislation-and-guidance_en (checked 2026-11-18)
  • European Commission – CBAM Registry (O3CI portal) – https://taxation-customs.ec.europa.eu/carbon-border-adjustment-mechanism/cbam-registry_en (checked 2026-11-18)
  • Semtrio case study – Tosyalı Holding (link above) (checked 2026-11-18)

Get in touch

Let's talk about what you're working on.

If something you've read here connects to a live project, a reporting deadline, or a decision you're weighing — we're happy to have a useful conversation.

Contact us

Related reading

CBAM for non-EU exporters: the EU declarant files the declaration, the exporter's installation supplies verified emissions data

Regulation & Compliance

7 Min18 Nov 26

CBAM for non-EU exporters: who files the declaration, what you supply

Read
Comparison of corporate Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions with CBAM embedded emissions per tonne of product

Regulation & Compliance

7 Min18 Nov 26

CBAM embedded emissions vs Scope 1, 2 and 3: why your inventory falls short

Read
CBAM reporting software checklist: eight checks before buying, with the first annual declaration due 30 September 2027

Regulation & Compliance

7 Min18 Nov 26

CBAM reporting software: 8 checks before you buy a tool

Read

Get in Touch With Our Experts

Lets talk about your sustainability goals.